On Civil Rights Leaders That Are Loved and Conveniently Dead

Posted 3 October, 2007 at 1:54 am by Kevin
Filed Under Racism |

David Schraub, over at the Debate Link, has an excellent post up in response to my Elliott’s Law post.

Many contemporary anti-racism activists have expressed frustration in the way MLK–and indeed, the entire 60s civil rights movement–has been “neutered” so as to mask just how radical and revolutionary its agenda was (and, by extension, how far short we fell from achieving it). I’ve noticed, along with this, a meme that floats around the conservative right that tries to split the “good” civil rights activists of the 60s, whose cause was laudable and just (though not, it’s worth noting, during the 60s themselves, as anyone who has read National Review articles from that time knows) from the next generation of Black leaders, who are charlatans and “race-baiters.”((I have to add that I see the same meme being floated amongst many “progressives” and “liberals” as well)) Dr. King is the emblem of the former group, and perhaps its only political member; virtually no other civil rights pioneer of that era gets similar treatment. Dr. King serves as an apt model because he is quite conveniently dead, and thus unable to take positions that might be inopportune for his more conservative supporters. Had he not been assassinated, I firmly believe that White America would not have accorded King his current valorized status, for the precise reason that it would have been that much more difficult to mythologize his legacy if he was alive to contest it. Hence we have the title of the post: The only “good” civil rights leaders is, quite literally, a dead one.

Sphere: Related Content


Tags:,


You can follow any comments to this article through the RSS 2.0 feed. Comments are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

5 Responses to “On Civil Rights Leaders That Are Loved and Conveniently Dead”

  1. Phil on October 3rd, 2007 10:08 am permalink

    It seems to me that there is a circular logic which connects the widespread (among white America) misconception that the civil rights movement of the 60s succeed in “ending” racism and this artificial dichotomy between MLK and contemporary anti-racism activists. That is, the purported end of racism leaves no valid cause with which these contemporary activists can engage. Lacking valid cause, these activists must simply be self-promoters looking to cash in on the legacy of MLK’s “finished” movement. Thus, a platform emerges for establishing a disconnect between these supposedly separate movements and retroactively de-radicalizing the older movement. This platform can then be used in itself to reinforce the logic of racism’s end. Pernicious.

    On the issue of “special rights,” another interesting way in which the 60s civil rights movement’s radical legacy has been subsequently defused by the right (and specifically in this case the white Christian right) is in the effort to pit MLK’s successes against subsequen queer civil rights movements. Not to say that queer issues regularly received widespread support or attention within the race-focused movments of the 60s, but white right-wing anti-queer groups have for some time been attempting specifically to gather Black support by preaching the notion that queer movements are corrupting MLKs legacy by even engaging in a discourse of “civil rights.”

    As I recall, there is some discussion of this issue here:

    http://www.amazon.com/Dangerous-Liaisons-Blacks-Struggle-Equality/dp/1 565844556

  2. sly civilian on October 3rd, 2007 10:34 pm permalink

    Word. “you do know he was against the war” is one my new favorite questions these days.

  3. bastard.logic on October 4th, 2007 8:57 pm permalink

    Thursday Blogwhoring…

    by matttbastard
    (Inspired by Melissa McEwen)
    bastard-approved blogreading for a quiet Thursday evening:
    Plucky Punk: Meanwhile…
    Angry Black Bitch: By Request - A new book…another cure?
    Impolitical: Stephen Harper is not a cowboy
    The Heretik…

  4. Rad Geek People’s Daily 2007-10-27 – White liberals on October 27th, 2007 1:12 pm permalink

    [...] enlightened for their ability to retroactively support the Civil Rights movement and to quote safely dead anti-racist icons, even though their present-day physical, intellectual, and political orbits remain mostly [...]

  5. No, this country isn’t racist « my place on December 9th, 2007 10:24 am permalink

    [...] enlightened for their ability to retroactively support the Civil Rights movement and to quote safely dead anti-racist icons, even though their present-day physical, intellectual, and political orbits remain mostly [...]

  • Tags

  • A Slant Truth Online

  • Facebook
  • MySpace
  • Twitter
  • Flickr
  • Last.fm
  • MyBlogLog
  • Goodreads
  • Utterz
  • Shared Google Reader
  • Honor Roll

  • *See also the entire blog roll*
  • Acephalous
  • Adventures in Ethics and Science
  • African American Political Pundit
  • Afro-Netizen
  • AfroSpear Think Tank
  • Alas, a Blog
  • All About Race
  • Ally Work
  • Amy King’s Blog
  • Angry Asian Man
  • Angry Black Bitch
  • Angry Black Woman
  • Angry Brown Butch
  • Ask This Black Woman
  • Automatic Preference
  • ¡Para Justica y Libertad!
  • Bastard Logic
  • Being Amber Rhea
  • Black Agenda Blog
  • Black American History
  • Black and Missing but not Forgotten
  • Black Folks
  • Black Looks
  • Black on Campus
  • Black Perspective
  • Black Prof
  • Black Women in Europe
  • Cahiers de Corey
  • Color of Change
  • Coyote Crossing
  • Culture Kitchen
  • Dagzine
  • Daisy’s Dead Air
  • Dallas South Blog
  • Debate Link
  • Diarly of a Black Male Feminist
  • Diary of an Anxious Black Woman
  • Donna Darko
  • Ebog Jonson
  • Egotistical Whining
  • Electronic Village
  • Elle, PhD
  • Eric Stoller’s Blog
  • Facing South
  • Faux Real
  • Feline Formal Shorts
  • Feminist Blogs
  • Feministe
  • Feministing
  • Feminst Allies
  • Fetch Me My Axe
  • Field Negro
  • FIERCE!
  • Fineness and Accuracy
  • Free Slave
  • From My Brown Eyed View
  • Gimp Parade
  • Girl Detective
  • Having Read The Fine Print
  • House of Nezua
  • HustleKnockin’
  • I Shame the Matriarchy
  • Ill Doctrine
  • Incite!
  • Jack and Jill Politics
  • Joan Kelly’s Weblog
  • Jon Swift
  • Jose Vilson
  • Kindly Póg Mo Thóin
  • Leftist Looney Lunchbox
  • Los Anjalis
  • Love Songs (Are for Lossers)
  • Marian’s Blog
  • Mighty Quare Dewd
  • Miss Crip Chick
  • Modern Musings
  • My African Diaspora.
  • My Private Casbah
  • New Black Man
  • Nine Pearls
  • No Cookies for Me
  • No Snow Here
  • Off Our Pedestals
  • Oh No a WoC PhD
  • Orcinus
  • Pam Spaulding
  • Plain(s)feminist
  • Postcaards From the Imagination
  • Present Progressive Mood
  • Problem Chylde
  • Prometheus 6
  • Queer People of Color Collective
  • Rachel’s Tavern
  • Racialicious
  • Raw Dawg Buffalo
  • Reappropriate
  • Renegade Evolution
  • Republic of T
  • Sex & Race Discussion
  • Shakesville
  • Skeptical Brotha
  • Sly Civilian
  • SmackDog Chronicles
  • Sublunary Limins
  • Super Baby Mama
  • Teh Portly Dyke
  • The Curvature
  • Theory of Noise
  • Theriomorph
  • Thinking Girl
  • This is Not My Country
  • Tiny Cat Pants
  • Truly Outrageous
  • Ultraviolet Underground
  • Unapologetic Mexican
  • United Black America
  • Vegankid
  • Wampum
  • Wear Clean Draws
  • What About Our Daughters
  • Why Am I Not Suprised
  • WOC PhD
  • Woman’s Ecdysis
  • womanist Musings
  • Women of Color Blog
  • Wonderland or Not
  • Zuky
  • Art Love

  • *See also the entire blog roll*
  • Autography
  • Mark Valen’s Art for a Change
  • Still Black Film
  • Xolografix Design
  • Podcast Nation

  • *See also the entire blog roll*
  • Addicted to Race
  • Black Women’s Roundtable
  • Georgia Podcast Network
  • Positive Hip-Hop Podcast
  • Communal Awards



    Brilliante Weblog awarded by Ms Lady Deborah (24 August 2008)



    Kick Ass Blogger awarded by Devious Diva (12 August 2008)



    Thinking Blogger Award awarded by Devious Diva (18 April 2007) and Thinking Girl (15 April 2007)



    Arte y Pico Award awarded by MsLadyDeborah (30 June 2008)
  • Open Source

    Free yourself from closed source software!

  • Linux.org
  • Mandriva
  • Kubuntu
  • Ubuntu
  • PCLinuxOS
  • openSUSE
  • Kick Ass Bloggers

    Radical and Progressive Bloggers Kicking Ass
    Join | List | Previous | Next | Random | Previous 5 | Next 5 | Skip Previous | Skip Next
    Powered by RingSurf
  • Stats